Difference between Metal Roofs & Asphalt Shingles

Difference between Metal Roofs & Asphalt Shingles

As a homeowner, you are mindful of the importance of selecting the best roofing system. With so many options on the market today, it is simple to become completely confused. However, you should consider the cost-effectiveness, robustness, aesthetics, and overall work required to maintain the roof while making your choice. There are many different kinds of roofing systems available. Metal roofs and shingles, however, are frequently compared, and to decide which is best for you, you must be aware of the important elements of each. Instead of providing dense, confusing information about both types of roofs, we have objectively analysed both types of roofs in this article for you.

Benefits of Metal Roof installation in Caledon

a. Lightweight

The fact that metal roofing is a highly lightweight material is one of its main advantages. First, throughout the roll forming and installation procedure, it’s simpler for the installers to handle and transport up on the roof. Second, it doesn’t weigh down or place undue strain on a structure, which minimizes frame damage and maintains a building’s integrity.

b. Longevity

The lifespan of metal roofing over shingles is arguably one of the major distinctions. Metal roofing is anticipated to endure at least 50 years before indications of deterioration start to appear. In certain cases, other metals like copper and zinc have even been found to endure 100 years or longer.

c. Lower Long-term Cost

Metal roofing is more expensive as a one-time expense, as we will describe later. Since metal roofs may easily outlast at least three asphalt shingle roofs (one can survive for more than 60 years), metal roofing is often less expensive in the long run (one lasts 15-20 years).

d. Fire Resistance

Metal roofing is the least likely to catch fire because it is normally Class A fire-rated and non-combustible. This is crucial in wildfire-prone areas since a metal roof is considerably less likely to catch fire if hot ashes or embers fall on it than shingle roofing would.

e. Weathering Performance

Metal stands out as the strongest and most lasting material when compared to other substances like wood, concrete, metal, plastic, or glass in both normal and adverse weather situations. When built correctly, metal roofing is intended to withstand:

  • Severe rain
  • Snow
  • Hail and ice
  • Extreme cold
  • Intense heat

f. Environmentally Friendly

There is no doubt that metal roofing is the most environmentally responsible choice for roofing, and this holds in a variety of ways: Because metal roofing may be recycled to a high degree, unused sections, torn-off panels, or damaged components can be reused in the future. Recycled materials are used in the production of metal coils and sheets. Since roughly 95% of roofing made of aluminium is already made from recycled materials, this is particularly true. The underlayment, which is used to protect metal panels from moisture, ice, vapours, and extreme temperatures and is placed atop the roof deck, can be recycled if it is made entirely of polypropylene.

g. Metal Roofing Might Help You Save Money

Installing metal on your roof replacement can save you money in several ways. If you have a metal roof, home insurance companies might give you a discount on your premiums. For energy upgrades, you can potentially be eligible for tax benefits.

Asphalt is less effective at reflecting heat off and away from your home than metal is. Therefore, metal roofing has the potential to lower your energy costs. Additionally, due to its high value and completely recyclable nature, metal is likely to be recycled. (Installing solar panels on metal roofs is also simpler.

h. Increased Property Value

A structure with a metal roof often has a greater property value (typically 1-6% more) since metal roofing lasts longer and has a higher initial one-time cost. This can also affect how simple it is to sell a building, particularly if the roof is in good shape and won’t require replacement by future owners. This can be useful if you intend to sell your house or other property.

i. Low Maintenance

A metal roof often requires very little maintenance, especially if it was installed properly. The maintenance manual from the manufacturer will contain advice on how to take care of your new roof. But once or twice a year, regular maintenance typically includes checking for leaves, branches, and other debris that could become stuck on the roof and in the gutters (and after strong storms). There are ways to clean your metal roof if dirt or other stains do not wash off with rain.

j. Insurance Benefits

Because metal is significantly less prone to fail due to fire, wind damage, etc. than other types of roofing, in some circumstances a metal roof could result in lower house insurance premiums. However, a lot of other elements, such as geography and other risk factors that could cause issues, also affect insurance costs.

Advantages of Shingle Roofing

a. Economical in the Short Term

As earlier mentioned, shingles are more affordable than metal roofing as a one-time expense (often less expensive than a metal roof), which appeals to many homeowners. The great majority of shingle installations are explained by this single fact. Please refer to the cost comparison above for reference.

b. It is easier to Install and Replace

Installation and replacement of shingles take less time and effort. Shingles are bundled and prepared to be nailed on the deck right away (unless cuts are required). When installing metal roofing, you must handle finished panels that may be heavy, fasten the metal panels to the decking with screws rather than nails, join the panels, and then install the flashing (usually consists of multiple metal pieces). The installer will need to put in more time, effort, and skill as a result of all of this.

c. Less Expensive Repairs

Along with being simple to install and replace, shingles are also simpler and less expensive to repair should a problem arise. Most shingles can be fixed with fewer materials by removing them one at a time close to the problem. Because the full-length panels are all joined together and more challenging to replace one at a time, metal roofing is more complicated.

d. More Installers

More contractors can install shingles than metal roofing since shingles are simpler to install. It’s usually simpler for customers to identify contractors that can install shingle roofs, however, it’s still crucial to select a certified and experienced roofing company.

e. Foot Traffic

Another reason shingles are simpler to install is that they can be walked on and will support an installers weight without damaging the material. The shingles can be utilized to walk on or support the installer while giving more traction once they have been fastened to the structure. The amount of foot activity on metal roofing should be kept to a minimum since excessive foot traffic could cause the metal to dent, scuff, or buckle.

f. Readily Available

Depending on where you reside, big box stores and regional distributors frequently sell shingles.

g. Coast-Friendly

Both metal roofing and shingles can be installed in coastal areas, although a steel metal roof’s warranty is typically not provided for buildings that are too close to the water. For the majority of coastal applications, an aluminium system is necessary to qualify for a manufacturer’s warranty. If shingles are damaged by wind, which is likely if your project is near a coast subject to hurricanes or high winds, they are heavier and simpler to replace. This is especially true of asphalt or composite shingles. In light of this, it’s critical to understand the region in which your project is situated as well as the wind rating required for your roof system based on that location.

h. More Warranty Coverage

Although metal roof guarantees are longer (since the material lasts so much longer), asphalt shingle roofs typically come with additional warranty options. And several manufacturers now give their asphalt roofing products lifetime guarantees.

Considering Your New Roof Options

To summarize everything, it can be useful to list a few advantages and disadvantages of each kind of roofing side by side.

  • Asphalt shingles are less expensive up front, but metal roofing is more durable and needs less upkeep over time.
  • Metal is less likely to need repairs but is more complex to do so.
  • Asphalt shingle installation is a quick and simple process.
  • Shingle roofs frequently need to be replaced after 20 to 30 years, although metal roofs may endure 50 to 100 years.
  • Although the average cost of repairs may be higher, metal roofs might occasionally result in lower house insurance rates.
  • When it storms, metal roofs are less likely to sustain serious damage. But during hurricanes, any kind of roofing could sustain damage.
  • Metal roofing is environmentally friendly. It is completely recyclable and can lower your household energy costs.
  • Due to its lesser weight than asphalt, metal roofing is less demanding on your rafters and foundation.
  • With any new roof, your home’s market value increases significantly, but a new metal roof increases this worth much more.

Consult our experts at AllPro Roofing Inc. We are available if you have any inquiries or want a second opinion on which roof will work best for your residence or place of business. An expert roofing contractor serving Caledon and the surrounding area, we will be able to assist with the inspection of your roof and provide advice on what will work best for you. All employees at AllPro Roofing Inc. have the expertise and dedication to perfection you’ve been looking for in a professional roofing contractor.

Contact us today!

The information provided is for general information purposes only and not intended to replace professional service. Please consult a licensed roofing contractor for advice and to diagnose any issues to best respond to your specific situation and needs.